Among the most divisive issues perennially facing the State of Israel is the blanket exemption of Haredim from military or national service. While this issue has long roiled Israeli society, the crisis situation the nation finds itself in since October 7th casts it in a new and existentially perilous light. Tamir Granot offers thoughts about why it’s so hard for different sides to even find a common framework in which to argue—and offers a suggestion for a way forward to a common future.