December 13, 2024

RESPONSE: The Biblical Etrog

It may come as a surprise that the Etrog is not native to the Land of Israel, but originated in Southeast Asia. How can we square our belief in the traditions of the Oral Law with the findings of history, botany, and agriculture that the Sukkot citron reached Eretz Yisrael only just prior to the Second Temple Era? Natan Slifkin offers an intriguing solution.
December 12, 2024

TRADITION Questions: Jewish Practices Independent of Halakha

For generations, Jews did not buy German automobiles. While there was no halakhic basis for this taboo, it reflected a Jewish collective will. Chaim Strauchler questions the meaning of this practice, and what it says about extra-halakhic collective Jewish action.
December 10, 2024

God Shall Be One

Our thrice-daily prayers conclude with Alenu’s call-back to the eschatological hope that in the future: “God shall be One and his Name One.” This prophetic vision serves as the animating theme of a new collection of essays, “God Shall Be One: Reenvisioning Judaism’s Approach to Other Religions” (Ohr Torah Stone & Maggid Books). One chapter, authored by Yakov Nagen, originally appeared in TRADITION as “Sharing Torah with the World.” We are happy to re-share it with our readers as we draw attention to its place in this new book.
December 8, 2024

REVIEW: Soloveitchik’s Children’s “Orthodox” Pluralism

Rabbi Soloveitchik advocated for strict limits on interfaith dialogue. Two recent books explore this issue in the thought of rabbis who, though influenced by the Rav, engaged in and sought halakhic mandates for such dialogue. Eliezer Finkelman reviews how Daniel Ross Goodman’s “Soloveitchik’s Children: Irving Greenberg, David Hartman, Jonathan Sacks, and the Future of Jewish Theology in America” (Alabama UP) shows how his subjects broke with the Rav, each in his own way. Alon Goshen-Gottstein’s “Covenant & World Religions” (Littman Library), challenges Sacks and Greenberg both for their justification and the limitations of their openness to other faiths.